Pick Your Plan
Only Crits started with one promise: dice and adventures belong together. So every order includes a free 5e adventure, yours to keep forever.
Instant PDF, delivered automatically by email at checkout.Couldn't load pickup availability
Each box includes a full 7 Piece Dice Set selected from our bestselling and limited designs. You will not choose the exact Set, but every delivery is table ready and quality checked by our team.
Flexible Subscription
You stay in control. Skip a month, change your schedule, or cancel anytime from your account. No long term commitment.
Share Your Dice With Us
Love your Set or think it should hit the main store? Leave a review or email a photo and your thoughts to mysterydiceset@onlycrits.com, Your feedback helps decide future Mystery Sets and may unlock special discounts.
Insured Shipping. Free shipping on all orders over $100.
Lifetime Warranty. Every set carries our lifetime warranty against defects.
60-Day Free Returns. Not in love with your set? Send it back free within 60 days.
Pick Your Tier
Same rewards at every tier. The only difference is the loot inside.
Plus shipping, roughly $10 per box, shown at checkout.
Avg value: $57+
Avg value: $79+
Avg value: $85+
Monthly Rewards
Every box is worth more than you pay for it. Here's the math on the Classic tier.
A complete polyhedral set, curated fresh every month.
A keepsake drawer box that stores and displays your dice.
One arrives by email with your order. The other unlocks by QR when your box lands.
Loyalty Loot
Not just dice. Odd-numbered boxes carry extra loot, and year one ends with our biggest prize.
With your first box
Money off anything
A free extra set
More loot as you stay
Guillman's Guide to Speed PDF, free
Overall rating: 4.6 / 5 from 206 reviews.
These are super cool. I've been subscribed for about 6 months, and so far this is my favourite set. The foil look is really unique.
Store owner replied: Thanks, Jesse! Six months in and this one takes the top spot, we love to hear it! The foil look really is something special. Thanks for sharing the photo with us too!
The monthly subscription dice feel good and play well. Also nice to receive a bonus every other month!
Only Crits Mystery Box: Regular Dice
Store owner replied: Thanks, Nick! Glad the monthly dice are rolling well for you. And who doesn’t love a little bonus showing up every other month? 😄 Happy rolling!
They're shiny, and a little sparkly, but what the pictures can't capture is the texture. They're so smooth, they feel soft and buttery.
Only Crits Mystery Box: Regular Dice
Store owner replied: Thanks, Debbie! “Soft and buttery” might be our new favorite way to describe dice. So glad you loved your Mystery Box set, and thanks for sharing the photo with us too. Happy rolling!
I have a new fovorate set a dice!!!
Only Crits Mystery Box: Regular Dice
Store owner replied: Thanks so much! We’re thrilled to hear you’ve got a new favorite dice set. That’s always the best kind of feedback for us! 🎲
Love the Bullet dice! They are right up my alley! Pleasant surprise when I opened my mystery set.
Only Crits Mystery Box: Regular Dice
Store owner replied: Thanks so much, Holly! We’re glad the Bullet dice were such a hit and right up your alley. Thanks as well for sharing the photo, we love seeing the mystery reveals! 🎲
Great quality dice. I didn't expect this Christmas theme at all, but it is worth the purchase 100%.
Store owner replied: Thanks so much, Benjamin! We’re glad the quality impressed you and that the surprise Christmas theme turned out to be a win. Really appreciate the support! 🎲
I got them as a gift for a friend, they seemed to enjoy it. The dice had a star Christmas theme and were pretty cute. I’m excited to see what the next one is going to be! 👍
Store owner replied: Thanks so much for sharing this and for the photo! We’re glad your friend enjoyed the Christmas-themed dice, and we love that you’re excited to see what comes next. 🎲👍
I really enjoy the Mystery Dice Set. When I opened this one I saw clear dice with white markings and thought, "well, that's sorta pretty" and was a bit disappointed. Then I saw that there was a winged figure inside each die. Cool! You came through again with another beautiful die set!!!
Store owner replied: Thanks so much, Michael! We’re really glad you enjoyed the surprise, and thank you for sharing the photo. Those hidden details are always fun to discover. Happy rolling!
The dice don't seem all that special for the price after taxes and shipping. *I'll try one more month and see what the next set look like.* (I will not be doing this now that I have seen better prices elsewhere for the same product.) I have better looking metal dice that cost less after taxes and shipping. I stand by my review of the first set of dice. However I upped my rating from one star to two because of how good the customer service is. Top notch! It really is a shame that the shipping is so expensive. The dice are a little pricey before taxes and shipping, and with shipping at 13 dollars Canadian really puts these into metal dice price category. It's a real shame as I have a small collection starting and was looking forward to adding cool unique dice to it every few months. $43.70 CAD is easily the cost of two sets of high quality dice from the local shop.
Store owner replied: UPDATE@ James Hey James, just following up here. We have sent out a replacement for you, and the tracking details have been emailed to you directly. Once it arrives, please let us know how it looks. We would really appreciate your feedback once you have it in hand. *** Hey James, thanks for the honest feedback. We appreciate you giving the subscription a try. We’ve reached out to you directly by email so we can look into this and help get things sorted out for you.
Love every box!
Store owner replied: Thanks so much, Steve! We’re glad you’re loving every box, and thank you for sharing the photo too! 🎲
There is just something special about the simple deep blue dice in the latest subscription.
Store owner replied: Thanks, Michael! We’re happy to hear the deep blue set hit the mark, sometimes simple really does stand out.
They are ok but not sure if worth the price since the shipping they charged was as much as the script. If it’s the same next month it will be my last
Store owner replied: Hey Herman, thanks for your honest feedback, we just sent you an email to help make this right. We really appreciate you giving the Mystery Dice Set a try and want to be sure you’re happy with what you receive!
The quality of the dice has definitely improved lately! My last two sets were truly stunning. I'm definitely lamenting the switch from pouches to boxes though. The pouches the dice used to come in were really stylish and practical while the boxes they come in now just feel like unnecessary packaging which just gets thrown away and then I have to find something else to store the dice in. A shame to lose a major selling point of the deal.
Store owner replied: Thanks for the honest feedback, Eddie! Really glad the last two sets wowed you, and we totally get what you mean about the pouches, they were a fan favorite. We’ll definitely pass this along to the team as we keep tweaking things. Appreciate you sticking with us!
The new Mystery Dice Set are absolutely beautiful. What a great color combination. I don't know the name given to these dice (I'll have to find that out), but they are definitely keepers.
Store owner replied: Thanks so much, Michael! We’re really glad you’re loving the color combo on this set. It’s always fun to see which ones land as instant keepers. And thanks for sharing the photo too, it’s awesome to see them in action!
These look great! It took me a minute to realize what was inside, but as luck would have it, the design is a great fit for a character I’ve been working on.
Store owner replied: Thanks for sharing a photo, Robin! So glad the mystery dice ended up being a perfect match for your character, that’s the best kind of surprise. Can’t wait to see what adventures you take them on!
I think I hit the jackpot with this set. Wow... absolutely gorgeous.
Store owner replied: Thank you for sharing the photos, Michael! Jackpot indeed, that set looks amazing! We’re so glad you’re loving it, and we can’t wait to see what you think of the next one!
Amazing Dice!!!!!the bonus was pretty cool also!!
Store owner replied: Thanks, Matthew! Great to hear you loved the dice—and glad the bonus was a hit too! Hope they bring some epic rolls to your next game.
This months dice are an amazing set of pastel like dice using a set of colors that in my head I would of thought wouldn’t look nice but in truth they look amazing
Store owner replied: Thanks, Matthew! We're so happy to hear that the pastel set turned out even better than expected. It's always great when the unexpected colors come together perfectly!
I love the size and beauty of these dice! I work for a Veteran owned free to play no pay DnD gaming lounge and Everyone one here is super jealous
Store owner replied: Thanks, Matthew! That’s amazing to hear—glad you love the dice! Sounds like you’ve got an awesome gaming lounge, and we’re honored to have our dice rolling there. Hope they bring you and your crew some epic adventures! 🎲🔥
i LOVE my dice! the details are so intricate and the quality is just to DIE for! (lol, lmao even). im buying subscriptions for my dice-loving friends for their birthdays!
Store owner replied: Thanks, Sarah! We're over the moon that you love your Mystery Dice Set! Hearing that you're gifting subscriptions to your friends warms our dice-loving hearts. 🎲💖 Happy rolling!
Definitely not regretting this box. Perfect fuel for my dice addiction owo
Store owner replied: Thanks, Marc! Glad we could fuel your dice addiction with the Mystery Dice Set. Enjoy rolling! 🎲✨ Can't wait to surprise you with more awesome dice in the future. Happy gaming!
I got some polar bear dice and they are so cute! I'm definitely looking forward to my next shipment.
Store owner replied: Thanks, Alyx! We're thrilled you love the polar bear dice from our Mystery Dice Set Subscription. 🐻❄️ It's awesome to hear you're excited for the next shipment. We can't wait to surprise you with more cool dice!
Charming set of dice, very happy here
Store owner replied: Thanks for your feedback, Joe! It's great to hear that you find our Mystery Dice Set Subscription charming. We're glad to hear that you're happy with your experience.
I was really excited to see what set I got, but I was pretty disappointed. They feel hollow and/or 3D printed, they're incredibly easy to scratch, and they came grimey with a weird texture. I also wish they came labeled with a name or something, because I honestly can't figure out what symbols are on the dice. I'm not sure I got the value out of what I paid for them. They do come with a nice storage pouch that feels premium. I'll try another month to see if the next month is any better.
Store owner replied: Thank you for your feedback, Alex. We're sorry to hear about your disappointment with the Mystery Dice Set Subscription. We apologize for any inconvenience caused by the quality of the dice you received. We appreciate your feedback regarding the material, labeling, and overall experience. We'll certainly take your comments into consideration as we work to improve our offerings and ensure better quality control in the future. We're glad to hear that you found the storage pouch to be premium and hope that your experience with future sets will be more satisfying. If you have any further questions or concerns, please don't hesitate to reach out. We're here to help!
Love these dice! I let the mystery dice inspire my character for an upcoming campaign. Going to have so much fun with these!
Store owner replied: Vincent, thanks for the awesome feedback on our Hexagon Core - Dice Tray! It’s great to hear it's improved your rolls and fits so well with your metal dice. We can't wait to offer you another product that hits the mark just as well. Happy rolling!
I decided to sign up for a subscription and received my first set (October). This is a very pretty set, rolls well and seems to be well balanced. My only criticism is that the 20-sided dice is a bit hard to read, but otherwise I love the look of the set and will be using it in my next game.
Lucky dip is lucky dip, you don't always get what you want. But even though they arent magically the dice of my dreams, they look cool and make that great dice-roll sound.
I just got the one time mystery dice set, but they're amazing! Fantastic quality, the colours are beauitful. Would get again!
I ordered two subscriptions and got two of the same set. Luckily it’s super cool! They roll well and feel good in your hand. I got one set for my dm and one for me. Great stuff, will order again when I need dice.
I have received 2 sets so far and I love love them. I never would have picked them myself but they are quickly becoming my favorite sets. The silver set has just the right contrast to make them easily ledgable with out distracting from how pretty they are and I just love the font on the teal set that is.
Wonderful great dice so pretty and love the surprise each time
I had to wait a while but it was worth it as I cannot find the dice anywhere on the site.
I got tiny metal dice! These are cool and I really like them. Had no idea there would be tiny dice.
Almost all of the dice I've received so far have been very similar color palettes and I'd like to see more variety in them
Super cute I love them and I can't wait for next month's set
Love these. They’re really pretty and they roll nicely. Excellent fun way to get new dice.
The size and font are confortable and Clear (also very cool looking) and the dice themselves are Pretty
Love it all
Received order as expected, happy with the dice i got.
Store owner replied: Thanks, Hunter! Glad everything arrived as expected and you’re happy with the dice you got. Hope they roll well for you! 🎲
Love the dice
Store owner replied: Thanks, Tyler! Glad you’re loving your Mystery Box dice. Hope they bring you plenty of lucky rolls! 🎲
Support
